The absence of black warrants (court orders setting execution dates) in India over the past five years has sparked debate about whether the country is reconsidering its stance on capital punishment. While the death penalty remains legally valid for “the rarest of rare” crimes, this de facto pause in executions reflects evolving judicial, social, and political dynamics. Here’s a structured analysis:
Current Status of Capital Punishment in India
Legal Framework:
- The death penalty is retained under laws like the Indian Penal Code (IPC), Unlawful Activities Prevention Act (UAPA), and anti-terror statutes.
Recent Executions:
- The last executions occurred in March 2020, when four men convicted in the 2012 Nirbhaya gang rape-murder case were hanged. Prior to this, executions were rare (e.g., Yakub Memon in 2015, Ajmal Kasab in 2012).
Key Factors Behind the Decline in Executions
Judicial Caution:
- Supreme Court Scrutiny: Recent judgments emphasize procedural fairness, mental health evaluations, and socio-economic background checks for convicts.
- Sentencing Guidelines: In 2022, the SC mandated “reformative potential” assessments and expanded mitigating factors in death penalty cases.
Prolonged Legal Processes:
- Death row convicts often spend decades in appeals (to High Courts, SC, and Presidential clemency). For example, the 1991 Rajiv Gandhi assassination case convicts were finally released in 2022 after 31 years.
Political Hesitation:
- Governments have been reluctant to sign execution orders, possibly due to human rights concerns, international pressure, or fear of backlash.
Global and Domestic Pressures
International Trends:
- 112 countries have abolished the death penalty (as of 2023). India faces criticism from bodies like the UN and Amnesty International.
Domestic Legislation:
- Paradoxically, India has expanded capital punishment (e.g., 2018 POCSO Act for child rape) while executions decline.
Case Studies Highlighting the Shift
2022 Supreme Court Ruling:
- Commuted 15 death sentences in a year, stressing “life imprisonment as the norm.”
Bilkis Bano Case:
- Despite convictions, public debate focused on rehabilitation vs. retribution after convicts’ release.
Project 39A Research:
- A 2023 study found 74% of death row prisoners suffer from mental illness or poverty-linked marginalization.
Is India Moving Toward Abolition?
De Facto Moratorium:
- While not official, the lack of black warrants signals reduced appetite for executions.
Institutional Reforms:
- Initiatives like the Madhya Pradesh High Court’s 2023 proposal to establish a “death penalty review bench” suggest systemic change.
Political Will:
- No major party has pushed abolition, but quieter shifts (e.g., commutations, focus on prison reform) hint at evolving priorities.
Challenges Ahead
Public Opinion:
- High-profile crimes (e.g., Hyderabad rape case, 2019) trigger demands for swift executions.
Legal Ambiguity:
- Without formal abolition, inconsistencies in sentencing and prolonged incarceration persist.
Federal-State Tensions:
- States like Uttar Pradesh and Maharashtra advocate stricter implementation, while others delay executions.
FOLLOW:https://newsroom47.com/modi-trump-meeting-key-to-shaping-indias-future/
Newsroom 47